instead of presenting her with the drug-store ring with the cursive G that I had bought for her, I sort of threw it at her from 5 feet away. She walked away, leaving the ring behind in the gutter.

In the latest in our new series, Graeme Rodway, Keith Melrose and Robbie Wilders collaborate to find the best bet of the day at Aintree. Here they outline their collective thinking. Keith Melrose: I ...