You’d think that as a host of a baking competition show, Emmy-winning comedian Nicole Byer would be into baking—but you’d be wrong. Or that as a Virgo, she’d be a hands-on, “Let me get that for you” ...

I have quirky business cards from places I stumbled across on road trips, coasters from girls' nights out, and postcards from practically every vacation. But these mementos either end up stacked in my ...