From his iconic Spirit Tunnel to his post-Oscars photo drop with Teyana Taylor, Aaron Pierre keeps blowing up social media.

Flowerpots bursting with bright geraniums flank the entrance, and a simple wooden sign announces what treasures await inside: “PIES • KITCHEN GOODS • COFFEE & TEA”—essentially the four major food ...

A gently swinging sign featuring a pie logo moves with the Indiana breeze, almost as if it’s nodding knowingly: “Yes, this is the place you’ve been dreaming about.” String lights hanging from the ...