As someone with about five eyebrow hairs, I tested these pencils every day, without fail, on rotation, drawing in my eyebrows in the morning and checking how they were holding up throughout the day.

From fine-tip pencils to smudge-proof tint pens, these top-rated brow tools help you fill, define and shape sparse or thinning brows with ease. 12 Brow Pencils for Natural, Fuller-Looking Eyebrows ...

When you’re looking for an eyebrow pencil that gives natural fill-in capacity that matches your eyebrow color, Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz Ultra-Slim Precision Brow Pencil is a quality ...

“This is a really good brow pencil,” Jenner said. “I’ve been through a little bit of a brow journey, working in the industry that I work in.” AMAZON $25.00. NORDSTROM $25.00.

With my years of knowledge as a beauty editor and months of testing the latest eyebrow pencils, these are my top 11 brow pencils that won’t break the bank.

Celebrities unpack the difference between the best brow pens and pencils—and share their favorite formulas to shop.